Please note: A expanded version of this story appears in our book Haunted Marion, Ohio.
Are there those among us whose senses extend beyond the natural range of perception? So-called mediums or psychics? Or are these people simply charlatans preying on the gullible and simple-minded?
A number of articles appearing in the Marion Star in the 1890s specifically addressed the legitimacy of local séances. The articles centered on the Woods residence, located on the corner of Fairground and Park Street (though which corner is not clear). This house was apparently the best place to take part in a séance in Marion at that time.
On February 20th, 1893, an article titled “With Unseen Hands” appeared in the paper. The unnamed author writes (rather tongue-in-cheek) that, upon entering the séance room for the first time, he “beheld quite a little multitude of faces unknown to [me] and three gentlemen friends who evidently as skeptics were present to wrestle with spirits.”
Mr. Lem McClaid, a medium from Ashley, conducted the séance, which involved a phenomenon called trumpet speaking.* McClaid instructed the three women and nine men form a circle and hold hands and begin singing. “Finally,” the Star writer notes, “one of the trumpets commenced to circle around the room tapping first this one then that and giving [me] an extra whack, evidently recognizing…a rank skeptic.” Soon after, voices began to emanate from the trumpet, and for the next two and a half hours, the group listened as the dead spoke to them. Members of the departed included an Egyptian who had been dead for 30,000 years, an Irishman “brogue and all” and, perhaps most surprisingly, a couple of dead locals, including one Robert Kerr.
At the end of the séance, the writer says that while he remains skeptical, he’s willing to admit that he is clueless as to how the trumpets were manipulated. Furthermore, even his three skeptical acquaintances present for the séance were “utterly unable to tell how it was done and glad that they had squandered their lucre in the exploration of the realms of mystery.”
Three years later McClaid still seems to have been in the séance business. However, skeptics were growing bolder in their efforts to prove that the sessions were nothing more than sophisticated trickery. In a Star article appearing on January 23rd, 1896, the author notes that during McClaid’s trumpet speaking séance, “One of the skeptics got down on his hands and knees and quietly sneaked across the floor to see who was doing business with the mouth end of the trumpet but was caught in the act and notice given that another such attempt and the séance would end without refunding the thirty-live cents which McClaid charged at the door to take part in the religious exercises.”
Of course, even in the 21st century, there has been no shortage of unscrupulous people who are willing and able to convince others of their supposed supernatural abilities. Case in point: according to a Marion Online article appearing on December 1st, 2008, Sherry Stevenson, a Marion woman claiming to be a psychic, allegedly convinced a mentally-deficient Colorado man to give her $30,000. In exchange for the money, she had promised him that certain parts of his life would improve. Police later charged Stevenson, who held psychic readings out of her 372 S. Main St. home, with fourth-degree felony theft after the Colorado man’s concerned relatives contacted them.
* In his 1907 book Physical Phenomena of Spiritualism, Hereward Carrington explains “trumpet speaking” as follows:
There are mediums known as “trumpet mediums,” whose specialty is the production of voices, etc. thorough a trumpet, these voices often being recognized by sitters as characteristic of their departed friends, as giving information previously unknown to them, etc.
In the vast majority of cases, the trumpet talking is done by the medium himself. If the séance is in the dark, the medium’s task is an easy one, he having only to wave the trumpet about and imitate whatever voices he desires. By attaching a trumpet to the end of the telescopic rod…and moving this about, voices can be made to appear in various parts of the room at will. Sometimes the trumpet is partly in sight, when the room is only partially darkened, and yet the voices come. This is accomplished by a small piece of rubber tubing being attached to the mouth of the horn, and the medium speaks into the other end of this tube. The voice appears to issue from the horn. At other times the medium employs a second trumpet, speaking into that, and it is almost impossible to distinguish the difference by locating the sound. At other times the medium consents to be held by two sitters while the horn is doing the talking. When this is the case, the medium generally has a confederate, who manipulates the horn, does the talking, etc.
Incidentally, not all of the séances conducted at the Woods residence involved trumpet speaking. An article appearing in the Star on March 6th, 1896, describes how two mediums from Cleveland, Mr. and Mrs. Lindy, conducted a ‘light’ séance (i.e. they kept the lights on during the séance).
For this particular séance, Mr. Lindy allowed audience members to tie his hands together and then sew the sleeves of his jacket to his trousers. The article states that, “During the evening cut flowers were passed out from behind the curtain by hands that could be seen, bells were seen to come up from behind one of the curtains and touch him on the head, and then the audience threw their handkerchiefs into the medium and they were passed out stamped” (in this case “stamped” means folded). The Star journalist’s only response to this manifestation of the spiritual world was a backhanded compliment: “The deception was clever.”